Dodgers historic postseason home runs fetch big bucks at auction

Easing the Blow: A Canadian Father’s Legacy in Baseball’s Biggest Night

The world of baseball is filled with unforgettable moments, where fans become part of history. In a dramatic twist in Game 7 of the World Series, a Canadian father-son duo found themselves positioned perfectly to turn heartbreak into financial triumph. John and Matthew Bains, loyal Toronto Blue Jays supporters, caught not one, but two crucial home run balls during the game—a moment etched in the annals of both their lives and baseball history.

The excitement unfolded as the Dodgers faced off against the Blue Jays. John, aged 61, skillfully caught Miguel Rojas’ 387-foot home run in the ninth inning. Two innings later, Matthew followed suit, snagging Will Smith’s decisive homer as it bounced into his hands. Their impeccable timing and strategic seating paid off, turning what could have been a painful loss into a profitable venture. These two fans, seasoned in the art of catching baseballs, had a plan that superseded their loyalty to their team.

The Bains’ experience underscores a paradox in sports fandom: the fine line between loyalty to a team and recognizing opportunities when they arise. They showcased a savvy understanding of the game, having previously caught a home run during the American League Division Series against the New York Yankees. Their calculated decision to sit in a high-traffic area near the outfield signifies a deeper connection to baseball that combines passion with practical foresight. This season, they weren’t just there to cheer—they had their eyes set on making the most of the event.

In a remarkable turn of events, the two home run balls were auctioned off, bringing in astounding sums. Will Smith’s ball sold for $168,000, which provided the winning run for the Dodgers, while Rojas’ ball fetched $156,000. This high-stakes auction highlighted how collectible sports memorabilia can transform a singular moment in time into significant financial gain. The Bains’ actions, though seemingly simple, illustrate how fans can navigate the complexities of sports culture and asset value, all while remaining rooted in their fandom.

In comparison to the Bains’ earnings, another auction item from the same event further illustrated the soaring values of historic baseball memorabilia. Shohei Ohtani’s remarkable performance during the 2025 postseason saw one of his home run balls sell for a staggering $270,000. Ohtani’s feat, where he hit three home runs and struck out ten batters in a single game, is often regarded as one of the greatest performances in baseball history. The contrasting fortunes of the Bains and Ohtani’s achievements spotlight a unique aspect of the sports landscape—how history often intertwines with individual moments to create lasting legacies, both on and off the field.

Behind every great ball caught, there’s a story waiting to be told. Carlo Mendoza, a 26-year-old Los Angeles fan, found himself unraveling his own shocking tale when he retrieved Ohtani’s ball. Having been further behind the right-field pavilion, Mendoza dashed toward the sound of the ball landing and claimed it from a bush, showcasing the lengths fans are willing to go to connect with sporting luminaries. Each of these narratives underscores that the relationship between fans and baseball extends beyond the game itself—it involves a blend of anticipation, luck, and the thrill of the chase.

Authentication played a crucial role in these transactions, as SCP Auctions ensured the legitimacy of the items. By employing notarized affidavits and lie detector tests, the auction house safeguarded the integrity of the sale. As David Kohler, the owner of SCP Auctions, revealed, there was no contestation or rivalry regarding the provenance of the baseballs. This emphasis on verification reflects an important aspect of the sports memorabilia market, where authenticity can significantly influence the value of collectibles.

In conclusion, John and Matthew Bains turned a heart-wrenching moment for the Toronto Blue Jays into a triumphant financial success, illustrating the emotional complexity tied to sports fandom. Their story resonates deeply within the community of baseball enthusiasts, raising questions about loyalty, opportunity, and the intersection of sports and commerce. In a sport filled with moments that can change lives, the Bains have carved a niche for themselves, melding their passion for the game with a keen understanding of its economics. As auctions continue to transform the value of even the simplest ball, fans everywhere are reminded that every game holds a myriad of possibilities—some of which can be quite profitable.