What Makeup Artists Think of the 2026 Readers’ Choice Makeup Winners

Makeup lovers often find themselves on a journey to discover products that resonate with their unique beauty vibes. Interestingly, your pick of the best products may not be that different from those favored by professional makeup artists. This year’s 2026 Allure Readers’ Choice Awards further confirms this as many beloved beauty items overlap with makeup pros’ favorites.

To gain insights on the standout products, we consulted notable makeup artists Vincent Oquendo, Jamie Greenberg, and Kelsey Deenihan. Featured for their work with celebrities such as Jenna Ortega, Rashida Jones, and Hilary Duff, these artists shared their thoughts on the award-winning makeup products that also make their personal kits.

The Top Winners and What Experts Had to Say

1. Beautyblender Original Makeup Sponge

Jamie Greenberg swears by the iconic Beautyblender, stating, “The Beautyblender changed makeup application forever. I still use it constantly because nothing presses foundation into the skin in a way that looks as natural and skin-like.” The sponge seamlessly blurs edges, providing a flawless finish that looks expensive and effortlessly chic.

2. Haus Labs Triclone Skin Tech Foundation

Vincent Oquendo believes this foundation is a game-changer. Its lightweight formula provides buildable coverage while maintaining a skin-like appearance. Oquendo notes, “It gives my clients the perfect balance of coverage and luminosity without feeling cakey.” This foundation has garnered rave reviews for its adaptability to different skin types, making it a top choice for makeup enthusiasts and professionals alike.

3. NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer

Kelsey Deenihan emphasizes the unparalleled versatility of NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer. “This is my go-to for brightening under eyes and covering blemishes. It really does it all,” she says. The creamy texture blends seamlessly and offers a radiant finish that never looks dry or overpowering, ensuring it earns a spot in both personal and pro makeup bags.

4. Charlotte Tilbury Magic Cream

Both Greenberg and Oquendo highlight the transformative power of Charlotte Tilbury Magic Cream. “It hydrates while doubling as a great makeup primer,” Greenberg explains. Users rave about its luxurious texture and how it enhances the overall application of foundation.

5. Maybelline Lash Sensational Mascara

For those seeking a drugstore gem, Deenihan doesn’t hesitate to recommend Maybelline’s Lash Sensational Mascara. “This mascara gives both volume and length,” she asserts. Its budget-friendly price and impressive performance have made it a favorite among makeup artists and beauty lovers alike.

6. Fenty Beauty Gloss Bomb Universal Lip Luminizer

When it comes to lip products, Oquendo champions Fenty Beauty’s Gloss Bomb. He says, “The formula is comfortable and provides a beautiful shine.” With its flattering shade for all skin tones, it’s no wonder this gloss has clinched a spot in the Readers’ Choice Awards.

7. Tatcha The Dewy Skin Cream

Greenberg cheers for Tatcha’s Dewy Skin Cream as a skin prep essential. “It creates a beautiful canvas for makeup application,” she notes, emphasizing how it hydrates and enhances the natural glow of the skin.

8. Urban Decay All Nighter Setting Spray

For lasting power, Deenihan turns to Urban Decay’s All Nighter Setting Spray. “It locks everything in place without making your makeup look stiff,” she explains. This setting spray is favored for its ability to keep makeup fresh throughout even the longest days.

9. Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz

No makeup kit is complete without a reliable brow product. Oquendo champions the Brow Wiz for its precision and ease of use. “You can create hair-like strokes, which is essential for a natural finish,” he says. The variety of shades ensures it can cater to all hair colors and types.

Conclusion

This blend of professional insights and reader favorites illustrates that many 2026 Readers’ Choice winners hold their ground in the competitive beauty landscape. Whether you’re recreating a look at home or gearing up for a big event, these makeup products come highly recommended by experts who live and breathe the art of beauty. Explore the winners to elevate your makeup game and embrace the artistry that resonates with both professionals and beauty fans alike.

Ready to snag these must-haves? Check the links and discover which products can fulfill your beauty aspirations!