A Deep Dive into Fashion and Characters in Ryan Murphy’s ‘American Love Story’
Ryan Murphy’s upcoming limited series American Love Story has generated intense buzz, especially surrounding its portrayal of the iconic Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy (CBK) and the fashion choices that define her character. The buzz intensified when first images surfaced of actor Sarah Pidgeon in character, sparking a flurry of reactions from CBK fans. Many criticized the costume choices, claiming inaccuracies such as her wearing a polyester blend skirt that the fashion-forward Bessette-Kennedy would likely never don. Additionally, her supposed Hermès Birkin was the wrong size, creating what many deemed a fashion faux pas. In response to the backlash, Murphy clarified that these were preliminary test shots. As the series progresses, so too has the accuracy of the costumes, with Pidgeon embracing a more authentic CBK aesthetic.
In recent weeks, Pidgeon has been seen across New York City embracing the quintessential Bessette-Kennedy look—think sleek black penny loafers and chic nylon Prada totes. Moreover, she has undergone a striking hair transformation to an ashy blonde, further solidifying her role as this fashion icon. Meanwhile, Paul Kelly, who portrays John F. Kennedy Jr., has maintained a consistent wardrobe featuring sharp men’s suits and casual athletic wear, bringing a modern yet nostalgic take to the John F. Kennedy legacy. No less inspiring is Naomi Watts as Jackie Kennedy, who perfectly channels the glamor of the former First Lady.
As filming continues, set photos reveal how the show honors Bessette-Kennedy’s sophisticated style. For instance, on July 25, Pidgeon sported one of CBK’s classic looks, balancing loose-fitting trousers with a chic black leather bag and a navy sweater subtly layered over a white button-down. This outfit was a testament to the effortless elegance for which Bessette-Kennedy was known. Acclaimed actor Noah Fearnley, playing her former boyfriend Michael Bergin, also joined Pidgeon on this day, making the scene even more reflective of the era’s style.
Not only is the fashion notable, but the portrayal of relationships within the show adds depth to its narrative. Grace Gummer, stepping into the role of Caroline Kennedy—JFK Jr.’s sister—was spotted filming scenes alongside Paul Kelly at the iconic Russian Tea Room. Such settings and style choices create a perfect backdrop for capturing the essence of the Kennedy family’s multifaceted dynamics. Furthermore, Naomi Watts made a striking appearance in a pale pink top paired with a vintage Bulgari purse, embodying the ethereal elegance of Jackie O, complete with an appropriate hairdo that pays homage to the late First Lady’s timeless glamour.
As filming progressed, scenes were shot around various New York landmarks, including locations like Central Park and the New York Supreme Court. Kelly was notably seen biking around in a navy suit—John F. Kennedy Jr.’s preferred mode of transport. This attention to detail in portraying the character’s habits is crucial to maintaining authenticity, and it certainly adds depth to the series. As fans know, Kennedy Jr. was quite the public figure, and Murphy’s careful handling of his character extends beyond fashion, weaving personal habits and societal expectations into the narrative.
Another interesting storyline arises from JFK Jr.’s romantic history. The show also features Daryl Hannah, played by Dree Hemingway, showcasing JFK Jr.’s life before marrying Bessette-Kennedy. Their relationship, along with his connection to Carolyn, serves to exhibit the complexities of love and loss that define the narrative arc. As Pidgeon continues to evolve in her character, her fashion choices will undoubtedly remain a focal point for fans and critics alike.
In conclusion, Ryan Murphy’s American Love Story is set to provide a captivating blend of art, history, and—most importantly—fashion. As the series ramps up with notable characters like Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy, John F. Kennedy Jr., and Jackie Kennedy, audiences are eagerly anticipating how the wardrobe will evolve to reflect the true essence of these icons. Given the fervent response from fans, it’s clear that the series not only aims to depict historical events but also to meticulously honor the fashion that played a pivotal role in defining these figures. To keep up with the latest updates on the fashion from the set, check out the official fashion page.
