The Remarkable Mister Holmes: A Fresh Musical Twist on Classic Detectives at Laguna Playhouse

Laguna Canyon Road has recently made headlines in the crime department, but fortunately, the Laguna Playhouse has decided to bring on the world’s most famous detectives to help smooth out the chaos. In 2023, the renowned theater showcased Agatha Christie’s beloved Hercule Poirot and is now welcoming the character of Sherlock Holmes once again with “The Remarkable Mister Holmes.” This new production, running until March 30, introduces a unique and cheerful musical comedy twist to Holmes’s character, transcending the traditional narrative of mystery thrillers that audiences are accustomed to.

The production features Paul Slade Smith as the iconic detective, who returns with charm and vigor in a 20-song musical comedy accompanied by a fellow sleuth, Sheila, who is portrayed as a long-lost sister of Dr. Watson. This fresh interpretation of Sherlock Holmes brings a delightful surprise, as Sheila proves herself to be not just a partner but an observant detective with her own skills which complement Holmes’. Co-written by Omri Schein and David Ellenstein, who also directs, the show showcases a giddy and frothy atmosphere, typical of a modern musical while paying homage to its classic roots.

Musically composed by Daniel M. Lincoln, the score captures an upbeat and festive English music hall tone. Yet, despite its lively melodies, the production sometimes leans too heavily on sidetracks and convoluted plots, particularly in the early part of the performance. While the comedic and whimsical scenes are enjoyable, the narrative occasionally falters under an abundance of exposition. A peculiar standout moment occurs during a number where Mrs. Hudson attempts to seduce Holmes, deviating too far from the character’s established persona. Nevertheless, the production does maintain a clever interplay of musical references that evoke works by Lerner and Loewe, making for a stimulating auditory experience.

Despite moments of unevenness, “The Remarkable Mister Holmes” is well worth the visit. Smith’s portrayal of Holmes diverges from the typical portrayal of the character, showcasing a blend of urgency and peevish indecision reminiscent of Henry Higgins from “My Fair Lady.” His dynamic performance captivates the audience while navigating the ups and downs of his sleuthing journey. Co-star Shannon O’Boyle skillfully embodies the character of Sheila, providing a strong counterbalance to Holmes’s character. Her no-nonsense approach complements the plot and engages the audience’s attentiveness, revealing a partnership reminiscent of classic detective duos.

The ensemble cast shines brightly, with each actor contributing uniquely to the storyline. Notably, Darcy Rose Byrnes delivers an engaging performance as a charming hotel maid, displaying both comedic and soulful elements in her solo, “Phyllis’s Song.” Katie Karel presents a mix of mystery and allure as a shady countess, and Alby Potts’s role as music director ensures the tunes are well-executed, enhancing the overall auditory experience.

The production at Laguna Playhouse is vividly brought to life with stunning costume designs by Alex Jaeger, perfectly embodying the period’s flair while supporting the characters’ quirks. Additionally, Peter Herman’s whimsical hair and wig designs and Stephen Gifford’s charming scenic elements contribute to an immersive environment that enhances the narratives portrayed onstage.

For those considering their next theatrical outing, it’s clear that "The Remarkable Mister Holmes" offers a delightful escape into a whimsical world of murder and merriment, lingering on the balance of traditional detective tales with a fun musical twist. This engaging presentation invites audiences to suspend their disbelief and join Holmes and Sheila in their sleuthing escapades. Theater enthusiasts will find this production a refreshing take on classic characters, resonating well with modern audiences seeking humor and whimsy amid the intrigue of crime-solving.

Show Details:

• Rating: 3 stars (out of 4)
• Location: Laguna Playhouse, 606 Laguna Canyon Road, Laguna Beach
• Show Dates: Through March 30
• Show Times:
  • 7:30 p.m. Wednesdays
  • 2 and 7:30 p.m. Thursdays
  • 7:30 p.m. Fridays
  • 2 and 7:30 p.m. Saturdays
  • 1 and 5:30 p.m. Sundays

For ticket information, visit lagunaplayhouse.com or call 949-497-2787. Join the detective duo on their humorous adventure while enjoying the entertaining offerings of musical theater.