The Greatest Managers in Dodgers History: Top Picks and Insights

Welcome to the latest edition of Dodgers Dugout, where we delve into the pinnacle of managerial talent in Los Angeles Dodgers history. As we wrap up our series on the greatest Dodgers at each position, it’s time to focus on those who have led the team from the dugout: the managers. In this article, we’ll explore the top five managers based on their contributions to the Dodgers, alongside some recent team updates and player news.

Recent Updates in Dodgers Camp

Since our last newsletter discussing the signing of reliever Edwin Díaz, there have been several noteworthy developments within the Dodgers organization. The team successfully avoided arbitration with four of their eligible players: Anthony Banda received a raise from $1 million to $1.625 million, while Alex Call’s salary rose from $769,000 to $1.6 million. Meanwhile, Brusdar Graterol will earn $2.8 million next year, the same amount he would have made last season had he not missed it due to injury. Reliever Brock Stewart is set for a salary increase to $1.3 million from $870,000.

Additional news includes outfielder Justin Dean, who was claimed by the Giants but has now been waived, opening the possibility for his return to Los Angeles. Regarding Kiké Hernández, who is recovering from elbow surgery, the Dodgers might opt to delay his re-signing until he can be placed on the 60-day injured list, ensuring he does not occupy a spot on the 40-man roster. This strategic approach could lead to his return as a Dodger, barring significant offers from other teams.

A Look at the Top Five Managers

Now, let’s dive into the rankings of the top five managers in Los Angeles Dodgers history based on contributions and impact.

1. Walter Alston (1954-76)

Walter Alston managed the Dodgers for 22 seasons, leading the team to remarkable success with a record of 2,040 wins against 1,613 losses. His impressive .558 winning percentage includes seven National League pennants and four World Series titles. Alston was known for his calm demeanor and strategic genius, earning six NL Manager of the Year awards. He was inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame in 1983 and remains a pivotal figure in Dodgers history.

One storied anecdote from Alston’s tenure demonstrates his leadership style: during a particularly uncomfortable bus ride, he famously quashed player grievances about their aging vehicle with a stern message that won the respect of his team. His legacy remains a guiding light for managers today.

2. Dave Roberts (2016-Present)

Dave Roberts has made an indelible mark as a modern-day manager, amassing a remarkable winning record of 944 wins to 575 losses and a winning percentage of .621. Under his stewardship, the Dodgers have won five NL pennants and three World Series titles. Roberts is currently one of the few managers to maintain such a high success rate, particularly when utilizing analytics and modern strategies.

Despite facing criticisms during challenging times, Roberts’ growth in managing player roles—together with a deep understanding of modern baseball dynamics—has made him a respected figure among players and fans alike. His role in fostering a strong clubhouse culture cannot be understated, making him an indispensable asset for the organization.

3. Tommy Lasorda (1976-96)

Tommy Lasorda, perhaps one of the most colorful characters in baseball, ranks third on our list due to his winning record of 1,599-1,439 and two World Series titles. Lasorda’s charismatic persona and motivational skills resonated well with players and fans, giving the Dodgers a distinctive identity during his tenure.

Lasorda’s strategic mind was evident when he cleverly rotated players to prepare for postseason play, ultimately leading the Dodgers to victory in the 1981 World Series. His legacy endures through memorable quotes that showcase his passion and understanding of the game.

4. Leo Durocher (1939-46, 1948)

A fiery leader, Leo Durocher amassed a record of 738-565, claiming one NL pennant during his tenure. His strong stance for inclusion and equality in the face of adversity—most notably concerning Jackie Robinson—demonstrates Durocher’s focus on team unity. He famously told his players to respect Robinson for his potential to contribute to their success, paving the way for future opportunities in MLB.

5. Wilbert Robinson (1914-31)

Wilbert Robinson managed the Dodgers to two NL pennants with a record of 1,375-1,341. Known as the "Brooklyn Robins" during his tenure, the nickname was a mark of his influence on the team. Robinson’s interesting methods, including his participation in a publicity stunt involving a grapefruit drop, showcased his eccentric approach to leadership. His legacy reflects the early years of the Dodgers and the foundation for future successes.

Fans’ Rankings

The community’s involvement in selecting the best Dodgers managers highlights how respected these figures are among fans. The polling revealed Walter Alston as the top choice, followed by Tommy Lasorda and Dave Roberts, with each manager generating substantial votes that reflect their significance in Dodgers lore.

Upcoming Season Insights

As we look ahead to the upcoming season, the excitement builds with spring training just around the corner. There’s anticipation not only for player performances but also for continued managerial excellence. The Dodgers are a team rich in history and potential, aiming for another strong showing in 2025.

In closing, the Dodgers’ management legacy is filled with compelling stories, spirited leadership, and a commitment to excellence. Understanding these pivotal figures not only enriches our appreciation for the team but also fosters a deeper connection to the game itself. Until next time, let’s stay excited for the baseball season ahead! If you have any comments or suggestions for future newsletters, feel free to reach out via email.